Monday, August 8, 2011

Reflecting on Education

With so many grave events happening over the last 5 days: soldiers killed in Afghanistan, S&P downgrading US debt and the subsequent tanking of the stock market , I found another disturbing issue that is as much a past, current, and future concern for the citizens of America. The Department of Education Secretary Arne Duncan will issue waivers to schools who are failing their "no child left behind" evaluations. There is just so many things wrong with this I hardly know where to begin, but I will give you a thumbnail of my concerns:
(1) That there is a department of education that started in 1979 and US public education has regressed so much that. . .
(2) The Bush administration, misguided by a delusional congress, passed one of the worst pieces of legislation since the Patriot Act -- No Child Left Behind. Oh, wait, that's right -- THESE WERE THE SAME PEOPLE!
(3) We keep hearing about all the terrible public school teachers and how they are dragging these poor (both literally and figuratively) children into the squalor of lives ruined by sex, drugs, and rock & roll. Whoops, sorry, that was the excuse during my "school days".
This is the one area that I reflect on the most. I am a product of a rural public school system. I started school in a one room school house for which we had an indoor outhouse. Today that would be described as an oxymoron if vocabulary was part of the curriculum, but for us, off to the side of the room there were two one-hole stalls, one for girls and one for boys and they were divided and screened off by a wooden partition. Butttttttttt, I digress. Mrs. Haley was our old, stern teacher. She was a widow with two children who were a couple of years older than me, so Mrs. Haley wasn't "old" old. There were two half-day sessions of about 40 kids apiece.
My point, as I do have a point (though it is hard to find hats for), is that Mrs. Haley was the first in a long line of public school teachers over the 13 years that helped to shape some of the sense of the world around me for which I am grateful. Of course, when I think of growing up in a very small Midwest town, I can only describe it as Luke Skywalker did "if there's a bright center to the universe, you're on the planet it's farthest from."
As I don't believe that we, as a species, have changed much in the last 10,000 years (no significant increase in cranial capacity from Cro-Magnon man as one indicator), I can't see that the last 50 years would have brought any change in the people who have gone into the profession of public school education. I therefore believe that there are just as many teachers who have significant influence on the lives of students as there were when I was in school; perhaps even more since salaries have increased dramatically in the ensuing years.
So, were in lies the problem? I calculated that in the chronology of any one student over their K-12 education, teachers have the student 10 percent of the available time. That leaves 90 percent of the time that teachers DON'T have students. Now, that 90 percent of the time really hasn't changed all that much over the same 50 years, but things to take up that time, and cultural influences have.
To me the most significant change has been driven by technology. From the 4 TV networks (ABC, CBS, NBC, and CBC), 6 radio stations, one "city" and one local newspaper I had access to, the number of media outlets have expanded exponentially to the point where an individual can choose to isolate (or even segregate) oneself with media that becomes the world inwhich one can exist. The example I use for this is Facebook. You can build your ersatz community of 300 to 600 "friends" and there you can stay and chat and dally your life away perfectly content in that you have a community in which you live that (mostly) believes the way you do and sees the world the way you do. And if they don't, you can block them, the digital equivalent of shunning.
The second big change has been the school administration. My school was run by the community leaders of the day, mostly businessmen of the area, very conservative, working with a very small budget. The basic approach was "reading, writing, and arithmatic." So, it took a village to raise a village. But your kids were still the parents' responsibility, not the neighbor's.
What appears to be the two major differences between school administration then and now are (1) no federal government unfunded mandates or diversity initiatives or whatever and, (2) there was not a teacher's union although when I was graduating some of the teachers did speak about it in whispers at off campus functions.
Let's go back to that 90 percent of the time that teachers don't have the students' attention. What happens there is far more likely to influence the individual student more than any one lesson in math or language or whatever.
Could it be that one of the key factors in the success of a student at school is the parents and the home environment? Rhetorical, n'est-ce pas? While neither of my parents graduated from high school, both were advocates for education, particularly mine and those of my siblings. And so it was for my children and I hope that it will be for their progeny as well.
Educational attainment level is the single most influential factor on attitudes and behaviors of individuals. It is clearly documented in social surveys that I have been involved with over the last 37 years. Teachers' classroom success cannot be judged by the scores of standardized tests of their students when they have a small fraction of the time needed to shape the student particularly if there isn't the parental support and backup. I find it so hard to believe that I am in agreement with Sec. Duncan on this decision, but I am. I'm in disagreement with just about everything else. I also don't want to tell him I would gladly re-integrate his department back into HHS, but that's a different discussion.
Bertrand Russell said that the purpose of education was "to defend ourselves against the seduction of eloquence." I believe our system has failed the majority of our citizens.

No comments:

Post a Comment